RC EVOLUTION - 遙控工房 - 香港RC遙控車討論區

標題: orion lipo 3800mah 30C [打印本頁]

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-6 21:25
標題: orion lipo 3800mah 30C
just bought from KWS.
size and weight is almost as same as orion lipo 3600mah 25C
please check with HK hobby-LeoChan about the price

[ 本帖最後由 tekin 於 2008-6-6 21:37 編輯 ]

: 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

: 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

: 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

作者: lokei3502 時間: 2008-6-6 21:27
How much???

作者: calvinpun2000 時間: 2008-6-6 23:06
how much~

作者: xrvct 時間: 2008-6-6 23:20
簡直無敵lar，30C

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-6 23:25

原帖由 xrvct 於 2008-6-6 23:20 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

簡直無敵lar，30C

用得晒咩

作者: ALEXANDER 時間: 2008-6-6 23:32
幾錢呀!?
我都要買三舊~

作者: xrvct 時間: 2008-6-6 23:51
標題: 回復 5# 的帖子
價格簡直無敵！

作者: LeoChan 時間: 2008-6-6 23:55
if big lot had more discount support !!

作者: LeoChan 時間: 2008-6-6 23:57

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-6 23:25 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

用得晒咩

30C 114A
25C 90A

use BL Motor 2.5T in YMC Race !!

we group more people join YMC !!

作者: penny..t.o.p. 時間: 2008-6-7 00:14

原帖由 LeoChan 於 2008-6-6 23:57 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

30C 114A
25C 90A

use BL Motor 2.5T in YMC Race !!
we group more people join YMC !!

要試下 D 30C 3800 mah 可唔可以义滿電後連續跑兩次五分鐘 + 尾lap 先

作者: LeoChan 時間: 2008-6-7 00:35

原帖由 penny..t.o.p. 於 2008-6-7 00:14 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

要試下 D 30C 3800 mah 可唔可以义滿電後連續跑兩次五分鐘 + 尾lap 先

兩次五分鐘 + 尾lap 先

噤貪心 !

作者: penny..t.o.p. 時間: 2008-6-7 00:43

原帖由 LeoChan 於 2008-6-7 00:35 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

兩次五分鐘 + 尾lap 先

噤貪心 !

唔係貪心.......如果可以......鬥耀明义機都唔使帶

作者: cwk777cwk 時間: 2008-6-7 00:48
幾錢...我都想買

作者: LeoChan 時間: 2008-6-7 01:27

原帖由 penny..t.o.p. 於 2008-6-7 00:43 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

唔係貪心.......如果可以......鬥耀明义機都唔使帶

Charger ???

作者: gordonleung 時間: 2008-6-7 01:48

原帖由 penny..t.o.p. 於 2008-6-7 00:43 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

唔係貪心.......如果可以......鬥耀明义機都唔使帶

咁你快d試下到時話我知 ......

作者: penny..t.o.p. 時間: 2008-6-7 02:30

原帖由 gordonleung 於 2008-6-7 01:48 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

咁你快d試下到時話我知 ......

你係唔係我識過個 GORDON 呀

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-7 07:45
用25C玩4.5R都唔夠爆同埋排電都幾熱,用30C應該會改善.況且又唔喺貴.
至於用唔用得哂,睇你玩咩motor,如果玩13.5R當然唔需要30C,25C也可以.但玩3.5R, 4.5R就.....

馮sir你都有trakpower 4900mah 25C, 比較其他鋰電有冇分別? 我諗價錢貴幾倍,一定有分別.

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-6 23:25 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

用得晒咩

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-7 07:46
pls check with Leochan. the price is not expensive.

原帖由 ALEXANDER 於 2008-6-6 23:32 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

幾錢呀!?
我都要買三舊~

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-7 07:51
時問應該同3600mah 25C差不多, 但一定爆D.
爆嘅表現差不多好似IB和EP電的分別.
IB=30C
EP=25C

原帖由 penny..t.o.p. 於 2008-6-7 00:43 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

唔係貪心.......如果可以......鬥耀明义機都唔使帶

作者: kcmas 時間: 2008-6-7 09:18

原帖由 penny..t.o.p. 於 2008-6-7 02:30 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

你係唔係我識過個 GORDON 呀

9成la,我地成間房都想你試左先

作者: penny..t.o.p. 時間: 2008-6-7 10:15

原帖由 kcmas 於 2008-6-7 09:18 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

9成la,我地成間房都想你試左先

D 3800 mah 30C 我買咗 la........我都想試

........Gordon都轉玩LIPO la.......

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-7 11:40

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-7 07:45 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

用25C玩4.5R都唔夠爆同埋排電都幾熱,用30C應該會改善.況且又唔喺貴.
至於用唔用得哂,睇你玩咩motor,如果玩13.5R當然唔需要30C,25C也可以.但玩3.5R, 4.5R就.....

馮sir你都有trakpower 4900mah 25C, 比較其 ...

Orion 25C 唔足喎!!點比呀??

trakpower 4900mah 已經更正唔足25C

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-7 11:54

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-7 07:45 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

用25C玩4.5R都唔夠爆同埋排電都幾熱,用30C應該會改善.況且又唔喺貴.
至於用唔用得哂,睇你玩咩motor,如果玩13.5R當然唔需要30C,25C也可以.但玩3.5R, 4.5R就.....

馮sir你都有trakpower 4900mah 25C, 比較其 ...

買排紫label試吓d真25c啦!!

作者: gtimax 時間: 2008-6-7 12:06

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-7 07:45 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

用25C玩4.5R都唔夠爆同埋排電都幾熱,用30C應該會改善.況且又唔喺貴.
至於用唔用得哂,睇你玩咩motor,如果玩13.5R當然唔需要30C,25C也可以.但玩3.5R, 4.5R就.....

馮sir你都有trakpower 4900mah 25C, 比較其 ...

I have tested 20c 25c and orion 25c with 3.5r 4.5r 11.5r.
my exprience is 11.5 need 25c or higher for better punch(because motor is slow)
4.5 and 3.5 20c or 25c is enough.
for ec engergy 25c is too much punch for 4.5 already , very hard to control.

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-7 12:13

原帖由 gtimax 於 2008-6-7 12:06 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

I have tested 20c 25c and orion 25c with 3.5r 4.5r 11.5r.
my exprience is 11.5 need 25c or higher for better punch(because motor is slow)
4.5 and 3.5 20c or 25c is enough.
for ec engergy 25c is ...

brother tekin may be he only like Orion,
So he don't know Energy E.C. real 25C !!

作者: penny..t.o.p. 時間: 2008-6-7 12:19

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-7 12:13 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

brother tekin may be he only like Orion,
So he don't know Energy E.C. real 25C !!

呀馮 sir.......我地 7月會全班用 ORION 30C 3800 mah 來鬥.......

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-7 12:41
其實我並不是特別鍾意用orion lipo, 只不過唔知有咩平靚正又耐用嘅lipo. orion lipo是不是最爆我唔知, 但應該比其他牌子耐用同安全. 即使價錢貴一倍有多.
馮sir所講嘅Energy E.C. 25C, 我都想試, 請問幾錢一排???

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-7 12:13 發表 [url=http://bbs.rc-evo.com/redirect.php?
goto=findpost&pid=873509&ptid=83621]

登錄/註冊後可看大圖
[/url]

brother tekin may be he only like Orion,
So he don't know Energy E.C. real 25C !!

[ 本帖最後由 tekin 於 2008-6-7 12:54 編輯 ]

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-7 12:43
I see!
thanks for your share.

原帖由 gtimax 於 2008-6-7 12:06 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

I have tested 20c 25c and orion 25c with 3.5r 4.5r 11.5r.
my exprience is 11.5 need 25c or higher for better punch(because motor is slow)
4.5 and 3.5 20c or 25c is enough.
for ec engergy 25c is ...

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-7 12:53
小弟無知! 請問馮sir可以用咩儀器去test "C"數? turbo matcher, turbo GFX???
照計大廠應該唔會報大 "C"數.
請問唔知呢批3800mah 30C會唔會報大數??? 因為size/weight喺一樣.

小弟就無機去做testing, 但下星期會落塲用sensor試.

如有錯, 請馮sir指正.

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-7 11:40 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

Orion 25C 唔足喎!!點比呀??

trakpower 4900mah 已經更正唔足25C

[ 本帖最後由 tekin 於 2008-6-7 12:55 編輯 ]

作者: gtimax 時間: 2008-6-7 15:29
耐用同安全. for orion and kocam
must be very good la
they are matched 2 cells in the pack, always balance with very little difference in voltage.

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-7 16:55
although orion lipo is very little difference in voltage, I still use balancer to charge lipo everytime in order to keep proformance and safety.

原帖由 gtimax 於 2008-6-7 15:29 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

耐用同安全. for orion and kocam
must be very good la
they are matched 2 cells in the pack, always balance with very little difference in voltage.

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-7 20:55

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-7 12:53 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

小弟無知! 請問馮sir可以用咩儀器去test "C"數? turbo matcher, turbo GFX???
照計大廠應該唔會報大 "C"數.
請問唔知呢批3800mah 30C會唔會報大數??? 因為size/weight喺一樣.

小弟就無機去做testing, 但下 ...

你借排30C我拎上廠做test咪知囉!!
大廠報大C數點解唔會發生呀!!如果唔係唔使轉用kokam電啦

由其是佢一直全糸列產品都OEM之後越嚟越差.....投放晒d資源去做宣傳請車手,唔使賺你多d咩

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-8 07:12
Thanks for your share!
I will report the proformance later.

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-7 20:55 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

你借排30C我拎上廠做test咪知囉!!
大廠報大C數點解唔會發生呀!!如果唔係唔使轉用kokam電啦
由其是佢一直全糸列產品都OEM之後越嚟越差.....投放晒d資源去做宣傳請車手,唔使賺你多d咩 ;P

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-8 11:18

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-8 07:12 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

Thanks for your share!
I will report the proformance later.

the proformance just your finger test,Can I trust that

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-8 12:43
不如有機會借俾你試下, 但要等我試完先.

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-8 11:18 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

the proformance just your finger test,Can I trust that;P ;P

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-8 12:50

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-8 12:43 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

不如有機會借俾你試下, 但要等我試完先.

深水涉交收

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-8 12:58
馮sir, 甘你有咩好野介紹. 請指點下小弟同埋其他車友! 等我哋慳返啲錢. 如果你介紹的lipo喺足"C"又平又耐用嘅話, 到時請馮sir食飯(如賞臉嘅話).
如不方便公眾公開,可以pm我.

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-8 11:18 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

the proformance just your finger test,Can I trust that

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-8 13:03
不如嚟將軍澳試, 全部嘢我提供, 請埋你食飯(如你賞臉同有時間嘅話)
我仲有好多lipo問題想請教你.

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-8 12:50 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

深水涉交收

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-8 21:11
orion lipo喺kokam代工, 甘orion lipo即喺無報大數!!!
你話
"大廠報大C數點解唔會發生呀!!如果唔係唔使轉用kokam電啦"

但又話
"Orion 25C 唔足喎!!點比呀??"

甘即喺點樣呢???
請馮sir指點小弟!

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-7 20:55 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

你借排30C我拎上廠做test咪知囉!!
大廠報大C數點解唔會發生呀!!如果唔係唔使轉用kokam電啦
由其是佢一直全糸列產品都OEM之後越嚟越差.....投放晒d資源去做宣傳請車手,唔使賺你多d咩 ;P

[ 本帖最後由 tekin 於 2008-6-8 21:26 編輯 ]

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-8 21:53

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-8 21:11 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

orion lipo喺kokam代工, 甘orion lipo即喺無報大數!!!
你話
"大廠報大C數點解唔會發生呀!!如果唔係唔使轉用kokam電啦"

但又話
"Orion 25C 唔足喎!!點比呀??"

甘即喺點樣呢???
請馮sir指 ...

25c3600都冇擺kokam上?,而家30C又擺kokam上?,點解?

作者: calvinpun2000 時間: 2008-6-8 21:57
之前orion 4800..睇書好似就係kokam

作者: calvinpun2000 時間: 2008-6-8 22:00
原來我排3300 20c係

: 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-9 01:24

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-8 13:03 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

不如嚟將軍澳試, 全部嘢我提供, 請埋你食飯(如你賞臉同有時間嘅話)
我仲有好多lipo問題想請教你.

嚟將軍澳試..........跑街飛咩路面先??馬路??大塵嗎??一齊入TRC試哩??
一係PYC啦??入Track先試到嘢喎!!

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-9 01:25

原帖由 calvinpun2000 於 2008-6-8 22:00 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

原來我排3300 20c係

又如何呀

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-9 01:26

原帖由 calvinpun2000 於 2008-6-8 21:57 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

之前orion 4800..睇書好似就係kokam

4800得10C喎.............

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-9 01:29

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-8 12:58 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

馮sir, 甘你有咩好野介紹. 請指點下小弟同埋其他車友! 等我哋慳返啲錢. 如果你介紹的lipo喺足"C"又平又耐用嘅話, 到時請馮sir食飯(如賞臉嘅話).
如不方便公眾公開,可以pm我.

咁又得唔得呢??比你用手指試係咪準小小呢??
http://bbs.rc-evo.com/viewthread ... page%3D1&page=6

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-9 07:41
YMC都喺街場嚟wo, 唔好甘主觀, 街場唔一定大塵, 條track好咬地, 加上我已黏好膠紙鋪track, 嗰度喺私家路, 無車無人行過, 幾安全, 基本上同落場玩無分別, 小弟又有alex sensor.
小弟早幾年經常去啓德,PYC玩車, 自從去咗呢個街場, 已無衝動又無甘多時間落場玩.
將軍澳搭車去PYC,TRC都幾遠下. 近排都唔會落場玩la

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-9 01:24 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

嚟將軍澳試..........跑街飛咩路面先??馬路??大塵嗎??一齊入TRC試哩??
一係PYC啦??入Track先試到嘢喎!!

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-9 07:47
小弟唔明, 請馮sir指教下.
好多人都知orion lipo由kokam生產, 說明書/盒都有指明"Made in Korea by Kokam"
甘又點解呢???

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-8 21:53 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

25c3600都冇擺kokam上?,而家30C又擺kokam上?,點解?

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-9 07:52
當然你準D.

Thanks for your share!

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-9 01:29 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

咁又得唔得呢??比你用手指試係咪準小小呢??
http://bbs.rc-evo.com/viewthread ... page%3D1&page=6

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-9 12:31

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-9 07:47 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

小弟唔明, 請馮sir指教下.
好多人都知orion lipo由kokam生產, 說明書/盒都有指明"Made in Korea by Kokam"
甘又點解呢???

呵呵呵呵.....個包裝...說明書/盒都有指明"Made in Korea by Kokam"

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-9 12:36

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-9 07:41 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

YMC都喺街場嚟wo, 唔好甘主觀, 街場唔一定大塵, 條track好咬地, 加上我已黏好膠紙鋪track, 嗰度喺私家路, 無車無人行過, 幾安全, 基本上同落場玩無分別, 小弟又有alex sensor.
小弟早幾年經 ...

我從來都冇話可以喺ymc街場試嘢作準!!唔係主觀!!
你問吓有邊間廠家喺馬路試產品之後""敢""出post作準

唔係灰你,係你自己主觀啫!!
AMB會唔會準小小,用膠紙鋪track????唔好玩啦.................

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-9 14:17
當然街場唔可以同PYC,TRC比, alex sensor也唔可以同AMB比, 但小弟近排無時間去PYC,TRC試, 喺街場用膠紙鋪track用alex sensor, 只喺權宜之計, 好過無.

既然馮sir認為要落場試會好D, 甘你問其地有orion lipo 3800mah而落場玩嘅車友la.

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-9 12:36 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

我從來都冇話可以喺ymc街場試嘢作準!!唔係主觀!!
你問吓有邊間廠家喺馬路試產品之後""敢""出post作準
唔係灰你,係你自己主觀啫!!
AMB會唔會準小小,用膠紙鋪track????唔好玩啦 ...

[ 本帖最後由 tekin 於 2008-6-9 14:33 編輯 ]

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-9 14:20
都喺唔明馮sir以下reply, 可唔可以指教下小弟.

原帖由 馮馮ymc 於 2008-6-9 12:31 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

呵呵呵呵.....個包裝...說明書/盒都有指明"Made in Korea by Kokam"

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-9 15:06

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-9 14:17 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

當然街場唔可以同PYC,TRC比, alex sensor也唔可以同AMB比, 但小弟近排無時間去PYC,TRC試, 喺街場用膠紙鋪track用alex sensor, 只喺權宜之計, 好過無.

既然馮sir認為要落場試會好D, 甘你問其地有orion ...

你唔係以為我等你REPORT呀…SORRY

作者: 馮馮ymc 時間: 2008-6-9 15:17

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-9 14:20 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

都?唔明馮sir以下reply, 可唔可以指教下小弟.

咁咁……咁咁咁…………咪咁咁咁囉……明啦?

作者: gtimax 時間: 2008-6-9 23:43
we can't trust the test on track but it is a good reference, test on track will affected by some factors(will change) : temp. , traction, tire, motor, driver , etc.
discharge data can be a reliable data will not affected by factors.

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-10 07:40
agree!!! 非常中肯, 一般玩家無工廠嘅專業放電機, 落場用sensor試只喺權宜之計.
Thanks for your reply

原帖由 gtimax 於 2008-6-9 23:43 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

we can't trust the test on track but it is a good reference, test on track will affected by some factors(will change) : temp. , traction, tire, motor, driver , etc.
discharge data can be a reliable d ...

作者: yokomo 時間: 2008-6-10 08:57
標題: 回復 1# 的帖子
For that Orion 3800 30C, please kindly tell what type / brand suggested to use for charging. Can we use the LiPo charger with Built-In balancer for this Orion Battery?

Thanks All !!

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-10 12:10
I use muchmore silent charger + trakpower balancer to charge lipo, the proformance is good and stable but the price(charger + balancer) is quiet expensive($14xx). Trakpower balancer is suit for orion's lipo design without any modification.

As other brother information, B5/B6 is quite good and the price is not expensive($4xx-5xx). B5/B6 are including balancer port but need to modify in order to suit for orion lipo.

原帖由 yokomo 於 2008-6-10 08:57 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

For that Orion 3800 30C, please kindly tell what type / brand suggested to use for charging. Can we use the LiPo charger with Built-In balancer for this Orion Battery?

Thanks All !!

作者: yokomo 時間: 2008-6-10 13:43
標題: 回復 59# 的帖子
Brother Tekin,

Thanks for yr info. Do u mean Trakpower V-balance? Do u know how much this balance is?

Thanks again!!

作者: gtimax 時間: 2008-6-10 17:13
I suggest use a charger and balancer with data port, otherwise you never know the actual balance situation(voltage of each cell).......

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-10 19:32
yes, I use trakpower V-balancer and the price is $4xx.

原帖由 yokomo 於 2008-6-10 13:43 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

Brother Tekin,

Thanks for yr info. Do u mean Trakpower V-balance? Do u know how much this balance is?

Thanks again!!

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-10 19:34
I want to buy but no stock in KWS

do you know where to buy it?

原帖由 gtimax 於 2008-6-10 17:13 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

I suggest use a charger and balancer with data port, otherwise you never know the actual balance situation(voltage of each cell).......

作者: gtimax 時間: 2008-6-11 00:30
kws rc flight shop have stock!
charger 12xx balancer 30x

: 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

: 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-11 09:35
thanks for your information!
but I don't know how to connect to orion lipo??

原帖由 gtimax 於 2008-6-11 00:30 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

kws rc flight shop have stock!
charger 12xx balancer 30x

作者: 倫ae86 時間: 2008-6-11 10:35
師兄30c係唔係好快嫁呢?

作者: blee 時間: 2008-6-11 23:57

原帖由 倫ae86 於 2008-6-11 10:35 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

師兄30c係唔係好快嫁呢?

Whether fast or not........ depends on the motor, not battery.

作者: LeoChan 時間: 2008-6-12 01:40

原帖由 倫ae86 於 2008-6-11 10:35 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

師兄30c係唔係好快嫁呢?

more punch !!

作者: efour 時間: 2008-6-12 02:51

原帖由 blee 於 2008-6-11 23:57 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

Whether fast or not........ depends on the motor, not battery.

Are u sure ???

Will u get the same laptime using a good / bad battery on a same motor ???

I think probably not.

作者: blee 時間: 2008-6-12 08:47

原帖由 efour 於 2008-6-12 02:51 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

Are u sure ???

Will u get the same laptime using a good / bad battery on a same motor ???

I think probably not.

Obviously your concept is not correct. The motor provides the kinetic motion and the battery provides the energy. Whether could run fast, just depends on the motor. Battery is an energy source, and it doesn't provide kinetic motion to the car. Straight forward, without a motor, the car could not run (but your concept meant the car could run with a battery even without motor). Actually, you only could say better battery provide better performance. Only motor is a key component and to determine how fast will the car would go (like 3.5 turns would be run faster than a 6.5 turns).

作者: tomatob 時間: 2008-6-12 10:59
同一個摩打用唔同既電個加速同top speed 都有唔同wor,如果摩打唔夠energy 去推,都唔會快啦,就好似同一個v12 engine,用唔同既油都有唔同既表現一樣,所以係要兩樣都配合先得,唔係單係睇一方面

作者: efour 時間: 2008-6-12 11:00

原帖由 blee 於 2008-6-12 08:47 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

Obviously your concept is not correct. The motor provides the kinetic motion and the battery provides the energy. Whether could run fast, just depends on the motor. Battery is an energy source, ...

That's why I'm saying are u sure running a bad battery on 3.5R having the same laptime running a good battery on the same 3.5R............. if u say yes, please think twice and throw away your expensive matched battery....

Just refer to your concept, fast or not depend on motor. Please don't kidding me......... if so, we all don't have to purchase the "sky" priced battery for just 0.9sec faster la........ just buy a 2.5R or 2.0R to win the world champ la................

In real life, I and my friends ( say 10 cars in total ) all using 3.5R. Our skills are quite close to others, most of us running same car, sharing same setting. The truth is better battery ran A LOT FASTER !!!

Just sharing my experience, not asking for argue.

作者: blee 時間: 2008-6-12 11:22
The concept is very easy.

Assume
-- battery A could provide 30C discharge.
-- battery B could provide 20C discharge.
-- the maximum consumption of your motor is only 10C.
Then whatever battery A or B you use. Your motor still only need 10C discharge. I wonder using Battery A would faster than using Battery B. Obviously discharge rate would not affect the speed in this case.

Always remember motor is a loading and determine current rate. Battery is an energy source only.

** For the second case: If your motor consumption is 30C, then you may need a 30C battery..... otherwise, the 20C battery will become very hot, even burn up.

No evidence showed 30C could run faster than 20C..... and no eveidence show 30C battery would provide more punch. The punch effect doesn't based on the discharge rating but based on the battery nature (inside material). The discharge rate only tell you may use a faster motor and without generate too much heat and safe to use.

作者: jeffkam23 時間: 2008-6-12 11:23
其實玩快車
用MATCH電定LIPO好D架?
佢地兩種電各有咩好壞架?
唔該師兄們分享經驗

作者: efour 時間: 2008-6-12 11:47
I'm not scientist, I'm not going to find the evidence, I just want to enjoy racing / playing, that's all.
I'm not talking C output rate ever since, did I ? I'm talking about the quality of battery.

We all also wish that a cheap cheap Lipo can have same performance to that Kokam had provide. But I believe, this will never happen.

By the way, the real life ( no science evidence, sorry

) An Orion 3600, 25C is much much much a lot faster than Orion 3200, 20C. This is track side experience.

作者: tekin 時間: 2008-6-12 12:21
如果所有嘢一樣(car, motor, speed control, tire, gear ratio....), 用 30c 無論o係爆同極速, 都一定好過25c. 但以同一質素和生產商才可作準.

作者: efour 時間: 2008-6-12 12:33

原帖由 tekin 於 2008-6-12 12:21 發表

 登錄/註冊後可看大圖

如果所有嘢一樣(car, motor, speed control, tire, gear ratio....), 用 30c 無論o係爆同極速, 都一定好過25c. 但以同一質素和生產商才可作準.

101 % agree

作者: kitha 時間: 2008-6-13 13:07
馮馮ymc 聽你講你同d電池廠好friend

歡迎光臨 RC EVOLUTION - 遙控工房 - 香港RC遙控車討論區 (https://jk.rc-evo.com/xbbs/)